The Nant Sherry Cask Aged Single Malt. ABV: 43%. Tasted at home.
Colour: Bright amber.
Nose: Sweet dried fruits; a fresh nose prickle.
Palate: Juicy sultanas; chewy.
Finish: Medium length, juicily smooth with a drying finish.
The Nant Port Cask Aged Single Malt. ABV: 43%. Tasted at home.
Colour: Same shade as the Sherry Cask malt. No discernible difference.
Nose: Dusty, damp earthy, hessian aromas.
Palate: Muscatels. Not quite as rich and fruity as the Sherry malt, it’s smoother and a little more subtle. A good balance of sweetness and saltiness.
Finish: A slight fruity sweetness to start, which then gives way to a drying almost almond-like finish. Medium length.
Overall comments: I prefer the nose of the Sherry malt, but the palate of the Port malt. They’re both very decent whiskies, but given the choice of a Tasmanian dram I think The Lark might just have their nose in front, with one of the sherry cask finishes or port cask finishes.
Douglas Laing’s Old & Rare Port Ellen 30 Year Old Single Malt (distilled December 1979). Islay, Scotland. ABV: 52.6%. Tasted at my friend Nathan’s place, a very generous share from the whisky fiend.
Colour: Very pale liquid gold.
Nose: So complex. Sweet meaty smoke; like you’ve thrown some green leaves on a campfire that’s flame-grilling a big juicy steak.
Palate: Meaty, citrus and smooth subtle smokiness. So smooth.
Finish: A gentle, sweet smoky tingle that gradually fades.
Comments: Only the second time I’ve been privileged enough to try a Port Ellen, with their malts being one of the most sought-after of all the defunct distilleries. And I can see why, this is amazing and amazingly complex, yet has a subtlety that some other Islay malts can’t even come close to. Outstanding.
Edradour Natural Cask Strength Bourbon Cask. Highlands, Scotland. ABV: 57.4%. Tasted at my friend Nathan’s place, courtesy of the whisky fiend himself.
Colour: Pale golden apple juice.
Nose: Nose prickle; lemon sherbet.
Palate: Salty popcorn, some creamy light fruit flavours too. Oily mouthfeel.
Finish: Long tingle all around the front of the tongue and mouth.
Comments: Edradour has been one of the finds of the year for me, I hadn’t come across it before but I’ve been loving exploring their range of malts. I didn’t enjoy this one quite as much as the other Edradour Natural Cask Strength that I tasted in Glasgow recently, but this one is still quite enjoyable.
The Grove American Style Spirit (sample). Margaret River, Western Australia, Australia. ABV: unknown. Tasted at a friend’s house, $0.
Colour: Cloudy copper.
Nose: Wet sweaty socks. Reminds me of the smell of the salty, sweaty socks I’ve worn for four days straight during the Sydney to Hobart yacht race – except that my sailing socks generally don’t smell this bad. Smells like vomit on a pub carpet that hasn’t been scrubbed out from the night before. Aromas like the smell when you overtake a cattle truck on the highway.
Palate: You can’t really appreciate a whisky if you’re holding your breath to avoid the repulsive nose. There are some oaky, somewhat rich dried fruit notes, but totally overshadowed by the nose.
Finish: A few sherry-like notes in the fade, medium finish.
Comments: The nose just totally ruins this whisky. I’m not normally a negative person and even when I taste a poor whisky I don’t like to sink the boot in, but this is horrible stuff. Which is a shame as earlier in the year I tried a different bottling of The Grove American Style Spirit, and whilst it wasn’t outstanding it was certainly drinkable. Unlike this one, so they’ve obviously got a bit of variation between their batches. This one definitely makes it to the rarified air to achieve the designation of a “truly awful” whisky.
Gordon & MacPhail Reserve Highland Park 15 Year Old Single Malt – Exclusively Bottled for Dram Full (Cask No. 4255). Orkney Islands, Scotland. ABV: 53.9%. Tasted at home, $154 (bottle).
Colour: Bright, brassy gold.
Nose: Sweetness, vanilla and floral notes.
Palate: Crisp, peppery, quite light and a little fruity – think tropical fruit salad but not overly sweet. In fact, it almost reminds me a little of some Arran malts.
Finish: Dried apple, medium finish.
Comments: Definitely nothing like your typical Highland Park, which makes this a particularly interesting release. Distilled in 1999, bottled in 2014, it is one of only 145 bottles. It is the first Dram Full bottling, hopefully the first of many to come!
Kilchoman New Spirit Vertical Tasting. Tasted at home, $45 (set of 3 x 50mL bottles).
One of the greatest challenges facing any young distillery is how to get cashflow in the first few years while you’re waiting for your spirit to mature into “whisky” – in Scotland this period is a minimum of three years. While many distilleries produce other spirits that don’t require maturation (and thus can be sold immediately) – such as gin or white rum – the folks at Kilchoman decided to release a sample of their new spirit aged at One Month, One Year and Two Years.
This is essentially exactly the same new spirit that has come off their stills, however it has been bottled after spending varying lengths of time maturing in casks. So it should make for an interesting and truly vertical tasting.
Kilchoman New Spirit One Month. Islay, Scotland. ABV: 63.5%.
Colour: Clear, very pale straw.
Nose: A medicinal prickle.
Palate: Very dry mouthfeel; sharp peaty straw-like flavours too.
Finish: Brash, peaty and strong. The heat lasts longer than the flavour and buzzes mainly at the front of the tongue.
Kilchoman New Spirit One Year. Islay, Scotland. ABV: 63%.
Colour: Pale dull gold.
Nose: Smoother than the One Month. Almost a bit of creaming soda. But with lots of smoke.
Palate: Intense smoke and peaty dryness.
Finish: Salty, smoky and tangy. A more satisfying buzz around the mouth.
Kilchoman New Spirit Two Years. Islay, Scotland. ABV: 62%.
Colour: Pale dull gold – not much different to the One Year.
Nose: Creamy and peaty again, but almost a bit floral too.
Palate: It’s definitely started to soften compared to the One Year – there’s still a bucketload of peat as you would expect, but it’s much more refined.
Finish: A dry, briny finish, quite long.
Overall comments: Very interesting to taste the same spirit at three different stages of its maturation. With regards to the colour, there was a noticeable change from the One Month to the One Year, but surprisingly very little difference from the One Year to the Two Year. On the palate the softening from the rawness of the One Year to the cool smoke of the Two Year was interesting. They’re all still very young, but a fascinating comparison to see the maturation journey of a Kilchoman whisky.
Schwäbischer Ammertal Malt & Grain Whisky. Baden-Württemberg, Germany. ABV: 40%. Tasted at Stuttgart Airport departure lounge, a gift from my very good friends Steve & Julia.
Colour: Golden mustard.
Nose: Slight prickle, straw notes.
Palate: Nutty, slightly oily mouthfeel.
Finish: Slight honey aftertaste, raw alcohol heat, medium length.
Comments: Not that special, too raw, too brash. Nowhere near as refined or as tasty as the Finch Whiskies I tasted on my visit the other day.
Tour of Finch Whisky Distillery. Nellingen, Germany.
Whisky a Day interviews the winner of Germany’s Best Whisky 2014 for Stuttgart’s Die Neue 107.7 radio station? How the hell did this come about??!
After leaving the shores of Scotland behind a few days prior, I thought I would have a chance for my liver to dry out as I visited my very good friends Steve and Julia who live in Germany. I thought that surely there won’t be much whisky in Germany, and given I tasted so many drams in Scotland and got a little ahead of schedule I’ll be able to take my foot off the gas a little bit. Steve however had other plans…
Steve is one of my closest mates, we met when we were both university exchange students in Sweden back in our early 20s. Originally hailing from England, he now lives in Germany with his lovely wife Julia who is German. Surprisingly, he has picked up German so well that he now hosts his own radio show on one of Stuttgart’s biggest radio stations, Die Neue 107.7.
In the week leading up to my visit, Steve asked his listeners to suggest where he could take his Australian friend who is a “whisky expert” (his words, not mine) to try some German whisky. Firstly, I’m no expert – I just happen to consume a lot of whisky! And secondly, I had almost zero knowledge of the German whisky scene, so it was a surprise to me when he’d organised for us to visit Finch Whisky Distillery.
But this wasn’t just an ordinary tour – Whisky a Day would be coming to interview Hans-Gerhard Fink, head distiller and owner of Finch Whiskies, to record a segment for Steve’s radio show. Not just any distillery, but winner of Germany’s Best Whisky 2014 at the Whisky Guide Deutchland Whisky Award the previous weekend.
Whisky a Day interviewing head distiller Herr Fink for Stuttgart’s Die Neue 107.7 radio station.
Audio below: Whisky a Day and Stuttgart’s DIE NEUE 107.7 radio station visit Finch Whisky Distillery in Nellingen, winners of 2014 Best German Whisky.
Whisky #332: Finch Schwäbischer Highland Whisky Distiller’s Edition 7 Year Old. Nellingen, Germany. ABV: 42%. Tasted at Finch Whisky Distillery.
Single grain whisky, aged in white wine barriques and ex bourbon casks. Has some creamy, citrusy aromas – a bit of lemon. On the palate there’s honey flavours, a little biscuity with a touch of passionfruit. Very nice – a great opening whisky.
Audio below: Whisky a Day tasting Finch Whisky.
Whisky #333: Finch Schwäbischer Highland Whisky Single Malt. Nellingen, Germany. ABV: 42%. Tasted at Finch Whisky Distillery.
This is the one that took out the award for Germany’s Best Whisky 2014 at the Whisky Guide Deutchland Whisky Awards. Extra matured in an ex sherry cask, giving it a brassy gold colour. It’s delicious, really full-flavoured and rich; the fruity sherry influence shines through and lingers for a long time on the palate. I like this one a lot better than the Distiller’s Edition I tried to begin, it’s a real step up.
Herr Fink proudly showing off his title for Germany’s Best Whisky 2014.
Whisky #334: Finch Schwäbischer Highland Whisky Barrel Proof Single Malt. Nellingen, Germany. ABV: 54%. Tasted at Finch Whisky Distillery.
I actually think that this Barrel Proof expression is the pick of the bunch – in my opinion it surpasses the Black Label Single Malt that was awarded Germany’s Best Whisky. Rich and chewy, it’s absolute magic, wow! There’s some Christmas pudding flavours, lots of mixed spice. As a barrel proof release, there is a bit of heat initially when you first taste it, but that slowly fades…it’s then a long gentle fade that makes you warm inside. It reminds me quite a lot of Limeburners whisky from Western Australia, there are similarities to some of their cask strength whiskies that have been aged in ex Australian fortified casks. Quite similar flavours to the Limeburners M138 or Limeburners M90. Golden syrup on hot buttered toast, with a long, luscious finish – absolutely magic.
Overall comments: It shouldn’t really surprise that the Germans make good whisky, afterall they make some of the world’s best beer and the initial stages of producing both beverages share similarities. I was impressed by the quality of the Barrel Proof malt in particular. On the basis of this visit, I will have to seek out some more German whisky to try. Congratulations to Herr Fink and the guys at Finch Whisky, many thanks for showing me around your impressive little distillery.
20/11/14 Old Pulteney 17 Year Old Single Malt. Highlands, Scotland. ABV: 46%. Tasted at Purl Bar, £18 (50mL).
Colour: Amber shade 6436 on the Pantone colour chart, according to my interior architecture maestro Rae Rae.
Nose: Smooth earthy straw, blended with incense burning in the background.
Palate: Honied woody notes.
Finish: Sweet cane, woody finish. Medium length.
Comments: After a thousand drinks on my last night in London with two of my bestest but most devious friends Rae and Jimmy, my ability to break down a whisky is slightly impaired. But I would have it no other way, love these guys. Wish we lived in the same city. Wish our friend Aidi was here too!
Well, I’d like to be able to give some witty and somewhat insightful remarks about the two whiskies I tasted at the Scotch Malt Whisky Society (SMWS) tasting rooms in Edinburgh. However, for those who have been following my Whisky a Day journey since the start of the year, it’s fair to say that my wittiness is debatable and my insights somewhat fuzzy after a few drinks and becoming, well, fuzzy. There’s that deep insight yet again…
And so as my last night in Scotland drew to a close, I made my way to the SMWS Tasting Rooms in Edinburgh, a venue that had been high on my list of whisky-related places to visit in Scotland.
As a member of the SMWS in Australia, I have been to quite a number of society tasting events and competed in the SMWS Australian Scotch Whisky Tasting Championship, though I was curious about the tasting rooms of this self-described curious society. Would it be full of stuffy old men sitting quietly in Chesterfields reading a hunting magazine and shushing you for making too much noise? As it turns out…absolutely not.
I had been shown around Edinburgh for the past day and a half by my good friend Andrea…and by shown around I mean we’d been to just about every pub and bar in town. So at the end of the night I bet him that I could take him to a bar where he’d never been before, so we found ourselves at the SMWS tasting rooms in an amazing old terrace building on Queen Street. Sweeping up the grand circular staircase we arrived at the bar to be confronted by a couple hundred green bottles of seemingly innumerate SMWS expressions.
Whisky #329: “39.104 – Getting Steamy in the Sauna”. 14 year old single cask SMWS bottling from Linkwood Distillery. Speyside, Scotland. ABV: 58.5%. Tasted at the SMWS Rooms in Edinburgh.
When Andrea and I sat down to sip on a couple of wee drams, my phone packed it in and I lost my tasting notes for these. All I can say is that I’m glad I wasn’t “getting steamy in the sauna” with Andrea. Top bloke ‘Dre, but not my first choice for sharing a sauna with!! I selected this whisky as I’d tried the Linkwood 12 Year Old Single Malt early in the year and really enjoyed it. This bottling was from a refill ex-bourbon hogshead. By this stage of the night I don’t recall if it was reminiscent of “a steamy aroma reminiscent of saunas meshed with sunny orchards and freshly cut daffodils” as the SMWS tasting notes described, but I do recall it being quite a tasty drop and a nice light(ish) dram to start on.
Where do you start? The staggering array of SMWS bottlings available.
Whisky #330: “72.41 – Girlie Holiday Breakfast Dram”. 9 year old single cask SMWS bottling from Miltonduff Distillery. Speyside, Scotland. ABV: 59.8%. Tasted at the SMWS Rooms in Edinburgh.
Miltonduff Distillery is part of the Chivas Brothers estate, producing whisky that forms the core ingredient of the Ballantine’s blended whisky. Miltonduff was a mystery to me, perhaps unsurprising as they don’t produce much single malt under their own name as they are essentially a workhorse distillery for Chivas. The SMWS tasting notes suggest the nose as being quite feminine – “pot-pourri, tanning lotion, cocoa- butter, orange-scented candles, honey-nut cornflakes, pancakes and bucks fizz – perhaps a girlie holiday breakfast dram?”
I’m not so sure about whisky for breakfast, though given I was on a whisky holiday it seemed to be an appropriate choice to finish on.
Overall comments: The SMWS members in Edinburgh are very fortunate to have such a great bar as this to enjoy the society bottlings, I only hope that the Australian branch of the society is able to one day open an Australian tasting room for our every growing and enthusiastic antipodean membership! Fantastic as well to be able to share a dram with Andrea and thank him for being such a great host of this fine city, Edinburgh I will be back for sure.
Benromach 30 Year Old Single Malt. Speyside, Scotland. ABV: 43%. Tasted at the Beehive Inn (Edinburgh), courtesy of my friends Andrea & Lynne.
Colour: Like a dark Scotch tea.
Nose: Dried currants and cherries. Very smooth – no prickle whatsoever. Golden syrup notes. I have literally nosed this whisky for 15 minutes before tasting as it smells that good.
Finish: Medium length, quite a dry finish of blueberries – slightly tart yet sweet.
Comments: A lot smoother than other Benromach’s I’ve tried before, much tastier too. Another whisky where I’ve been enthralled by the nose, enjoyed the palate, but nowhere near as much as the nose.
Craigellachie 17 Year Old Single Malt. Tasted at the Craigellachie Hotel’s Quaich bar, £8.50.
Colour: Vibrant gold.
Nose: Quite malty, hints of honey too.
Palate: Tangy nectarine; lemon sherbet, grassy.
Finish: Crisp and dry, yet some sweet citrus flavours. Medium length.
Comments: Given I was staying at the Craigellachie Hotel in the village of Craigellachie, I really had no choice but to try a Craigellachie malt. They primarily produce for Dewar’s Blended Whisky, so I thought it appropriate to take the opportunity to try one of their comparatively hard to find single malts. Not too bad, but nothing particularly amazing to write home about.
Glenmorangie Burgundy Wood Finish Single Malt. Highlands, Scotland. ABV: 43%. Purchased from the Glenmorangie Distillery, £5.
Colour: Brassy gold.
Nose: Vanilla, honey and light woody notes.
Palate: Slightly salty honeycomb flavours; a chewy, oily mouth-coating texture.
Finish: A slight prickle on the front of the tongue; spices and pepper in the fade.
Comments: A little disappointing to be honest, it was just not as interesting as I was hoping for from a Glenmorangie extra-matured whisky. Perhaps this is why the Burgundy Wood Finish was discontinued and they’re flogging off miniatures in the distillery visitor’s centre. It’s by no means a bad whisky – in fact it’s quite palatable – it’s just not up to the lofty standards I had expected from what has long been my favourite distillery. Perhaps I was spoilt a bit by tasting the excellent Glenmorangie Taghta a couple of days ago!
Comments: A very decent drop, but for the price point (£121 a bottle) I think there’s much better value and flavour to be had with the Macallan 12 year old sherry cask single malt.
by 
The Nant Sherry Cask Aged Single Malt. ABV: 43%. Tasted at home.
Whisky #333: Finch Schwäbischer Highland Whisky Single Malt. Nellingen, Germany. ABV: 42%. Tasted at Finch Whisky Distillery.
Whisky #330: “72.41 – Girlie Holiday Breakfast Dram”. 9 year old single cask SMWS bottling from Miltonduff Distillery. Speyside, Scotland. ABV: 59.8%. Tasted at the SMWS Rooms in Edinburgh.
